NYC | Wendell

A Sharp Comparison of Faiths

During my most recent mission trip to New York City, I was struck by a severe contrast in feelings which I experienced while visiting an Islamic service at a mosque and a Christian service at a church in the same city.  

While visiting the mosque I was immediately struck by the mechanical, joyless devotion of the attendees.  I don’t believe I saw one believer with a smile on their face. Amid the reverence and ritual, I sensed an underlying atmosphere of coldness and legalism inherent in the Islamic approach to salvation. In Islam, the emphasis rests heavily on adherence to laws and actions, where one’s fate is measured by a scale of deeds—good versus bad—on the Day of Judgment. This legalistic framework breeds a sense of uncertainty among believers, as they grapple with the insufficiency of their efforts, always striving for a divine approval that seems perpetually out of reach.  I came away from the service devoid of hope and with a deep sense of despair.

In stark contrast while attending services at a Christian church in the city, we missionaries experienced a celebration of the gift of salvation provided to us all.  Multi-lingual sermons, loud energetic gospel music, flags and even a pair of ram’s horns were all part of the celebration of faith.  People from many cultural backgrounds were there to celebrate the message of salvation in Christianity which provides a warm, loving certainty that stands as a beacon of hope. Smiles and tears of joy filled the sanctuary.  It was clear that those in attendance take to heart the Christian belief that salvation is a gift, unearned and freely given through faith in Jesus Christ. Unlike the burden of rigorous law, Christianity offers individuals an intimate relationship with God, grounded in grace. This assurance not only frees believers from the fear of judgment but also invites them to experience a profound acceptance and love. The assurance found in the New Testament—that no one can earn salvation through their own merit—allows Christians to rest in the certainty of their faith, fostering a community driven by love, forgiveness, and support.  I came away from that service feeling an overflowing sense of hope, joy and love.

When comparing both visits I can’t help but think of the pivotal moment when Abraham’s decision to father Ishmael through his own ability instead of fully trusting in God’s promise, which culminated in the birth of Isaac. This decision marks a significant divergence in faith narratives; it symbolizes a reliance on human effort and understanding that ultimately incubated a path of legalism within Islam.  Conversely, Isaac’s birth represents a promise fulfilled through divine trust, laying the groundwork for a faith that celebrates God’s grace and intervention.  

My heart breaks for the unreached people groups in Islam.  It is my fervent prayer that we will continue to have success while working with the full-time missionaries in New York City in replacing this yoke of despair and legalism with the glorious gift of salvation.

Wendell Davis, New York City 2025